A World Trade Magazine article on apparel logistics, January 1, 2004 — with Bill Cantrell of Apparel Search Logistics on supply chains, quotas and security.
On January 1, 2004, World Trade Magazine (worldtrademag.com) published “A Stitch In Time,” written by Jeremy N. Smith. The article opens on a simple truth of the trade: the window of opportunity slams shut fast in the world of retail fashion. Few sectors of the American economy rely more on modern logistics than the apparel industry, and the piece set out to learn, from two working consultants, how successful companies can focus on logistics fundamentals without falling behind on new developments.

World Trade talked to Bill Cantrell, Managing Director of Apparel Search Logistics, and Monica Isbell, principal of Starboard Alliance Company. Between them, the two laid out the structure of the industry as it stood at the start of 2004: American apparel leaders acting more as importers than as manufacturers, contracting production out to third-party factories because garment assembly, testing and packaging demand so much human contact that manufacturing follows low-cost labor above all.
“Most apparel companies don't own their manufacturing,” Isbell explained. “They are contracting out to third-party factories and importing their product.” Cantrell added the shopper's-eye view: in almost any major U.S. retailer, a customer would be hard-pressed to find the “Made in USA” items that were once prevalent. Isbell traced the migration of sourcing over twenty years — beginning in Japan and Korea, then shifting as those economies developed to China and Southeast Asia, and on to the Caribbean basin, Latin America and Mexico.
Inexpensive labor, the article notes, comes at the price of more expensive transportation, distribution and storage. Supply chain costs across sectors make up about ten percent of the cost of goods sold within the United States; sourcing from Latin America raises that to fifteen to seventeen percent, and from China to twenty-two to twenty-six percent — “and in the apparel industry, those costs are actually quite a bit higher,” Cantrell said, because the timing is tighter.
“Apparel importers operate under very tight windows,” Isbell explained. “If their vendor isn't on time, if it's a high-end item, or if it's trendy, they're going to have to use air freight to get their products to the store.” Flying fashion — from simple cotton shirts to thousand-dollar business suits — costs ten times ocean freight, yet not flying a hot seller costs more: “Every day it's not in the store, it can't be sold.” The remedy both consultants recommended was vendor compliance programs that actively monitor performance, down to how full vendors load shipping containers, with real penalties behind them. “Put teeth into your penalties and you quickly get compliance from your vendors,” Isbell agreed, citing major merchants such as Wal-Mart as leaders that push logistics work out onto their suppliers.
The article's second half looks at the end of the quota system. Trade agreements had long restricted where companies could import from, and in what quantity; as negotiated in the 1995 Uruguay round of World Trade Organization talks, quotas for clothing imports were ending — February 1, 2004 in the article's account, with restrictions on China remaining until 2008. “At the moment, quotas govern the whole import process for apparels,” Isbell said. “People in the apparel industry are very nervous about what's going to happen with the end of a system that's been in place for forty years.”
With a real open market, companies would have to determine where to produce all over again, which meant an ever greater emphasis on logistics: taking advantage of a trade preference, for example, meant answering how much it would cost to move product to the U.S. from Kenya rather than Hong Kong, and finding a carrier who could do it on time at an acceptable cost. Both consultants expected China to keep increasing its share of apparel manufacture, but discounted claims that it would swallow the entire industry — infrastructure constraints, port congestion and the sharp drop in logistics quality more than 100 miles inland from China's coastal factory belt all argued otherwise. Quota elimination also promised quieter efficiencies, such as apparel becoming eligible for customs pre-clearance so footwear and apparel could finally ship together.
The article closes with the security climate after the September 11, 2001 attacks, which raised the cost of moving goods across borders, and with the voluntary Customs-Trade Partnership Against Terrorism (C-TPAT) program: importers who follow Customs' guidelines across their supply chains earn a certification that Cantrell called a competitive edge — “If you're working with other partners in the program and you're not certified, you're the weakest link” — and one that can turn a fifty thousand dollar fine into a five thousand dollar one. The final advice is a full logistics review, from issuance of product orders to delivery to customers. “It's really about getting control of their business and processes,” Cantrell concluded. “Until you can measure it, how can you improve it, and if you do improve it, how will you know?” Jeremy N. Smith is based in Missoula, Montana.
A Stitch In Time is an article by Jeremy N. Smith published in World Trade Magazine on January 1, 2004. It examines how heavily the apparel industry relies on modern logistics, and it interviews two clothing industry consultants: Bill Cantrell, Managing Director of Apparel Search Logistics, and Monica Isbell, principal of Starboard Alliance Company.
It reported that supply chain costs across sectors make up about ten percent of the cost of goods sold within the United States, rising to fifteen to seventeen percent for product sourced from Latin America and twenty-two to twenty-six percent from China — and that apparel costs run higher still, because fashion importers work to very tight selling windows and sometimes must fly goods at ten times the cost of ocean freight.
The end of textile import quotas. As negotiated in the 1995 Uruguay round of World Trade Organization talks, quotas on clothing imports were ending — the article gives February 1, 2004, with restrictions on China remaining until 2008 — forcing companies to decide all over again where in the world to produce.