Combing

Miscellaneous Definitions — preparing carded fiber for spinning, from Apparel Search

Search Apparel Search

At a Glance

Definition: Combing is a method of preparing carded fiber for spinning: steel pins separate out the short fibers, leaving the longer fibers straightened and lying parallel in a flat bundle called a top.

Category: Miscellaneous Definitions

Combing is the refining step that follows carding in fiber preparation. Carded fiber still contains a mix of long and short fibers pointing in roughly the same direction; combing takes the short fibers out and leaves the rest straight, clean and parallel, ready for spinning. It is the preparation behind worsted yarn, and it is what the words “combed cotton” promise on a label: carded cotton that has been through the combs, with its short fibers removed before spinning.

Neat parallel sliver of combed fiber beside a steel pin comb on a work table
A combed sliver of long, parallel fibers, with the steel pins that separated out the short fibers.

A Filter That Removes the Short Fibers

Combing separates out the short fibers from carded fiber by means of a rotating ring or a rectilinear row of steel pins. What survives the process is a bundle in which the fibers have been straightened and lie parallel to each other, all running the same way. That parallel bundle is the point of the exercise: drawn out and twisted, it makes a smooth, strong, even yarn, where short fibers left in the mix would have produced weak spots and an irregular, hairy surface.

The comb works as a mechanical sieve. In general, combing is done to remove short-length fiber — fiber shorter than about 21 mm is a typical cut-off — and the setting can be adjusted, with a scale set so that fibers below a chosen length, for example 25 mm, are taken out. The sieve has one honest limit: it will not remove a contaminant that looks like a fiber being combed. Anything of that kind has to be mended out of the finished garment by hand, which is a costly process, and is one reason clean preparation matters so much upstream.

Circular and Rectilinear Combs

The circular combs used in the process carry long metal teeth and only barely resemble the comb used on hair, though the action is similar: one comb holds the fiber, which is slowly dubbed in by a brush, while the other comb is moved through it, gradually transferring the fiber to the moving comb.

The rectilinear comb works differently. A circular comb combs out the fringe and removes the short fiber that a clamping mechanism is not holding, while a top comb — a very fine comb, of for example 25 teeth per inch — stands in the way of contaminants such as burr and seed and keeps them from flowing through with the good fiber. The combed fibers, now called tuft, are overlapped so the bundle gains some cohesion, and the overlapped tuft is then twisted to form a combed sliver.

Gilling Before and After the Comb

A freshly combed sliver is weak and unsuitable for spinning, so combing sits inside a longer sequence of preparation. Carding is the primary process; gilling follows, worked through separate machines to remove hooks from the fiber; then comes the combing itself; and after combing, further gillings remove irregularity in the sliver and randomize the fiber ends. Only after that post-combing work can spinning follow. The research behind that sequence is substantial: it is known that a sliver can be spun to a yarn of only 21 fibers with a suitable average length of, say, 150 mm (CSIRO 1990), and Sokolov (1994) is among the authorities the original account draws on for the mechanics of the rectilinear comb.

Noble, Heilmann and French Combs

Two combing technologies competed historically. The Noble comb of 1853 — with variants by Lister, Heilmann (1846) and Holden — was the circular English design, while the French comb was a rectilinear system developed in continental Europe. The French system won: it combs the entire length of a fiber, where the Noble comb cannot comb about 2 mm of a fiber’s length, the distance between its counter-rotating pins, and is inefficient by comparison. Most combing in the world is now carried out on the French system. Part of the story is industrial secrecy: English mills did not share their technology, which pushed continental Europe to develop the superior rectilinear system in the mid 19th century, and the work of CSIRO later made both the Noble and French combs well understood.

Machine names follow the fiber. In cotton manufacture, the Heilmann comber was superseded by the Naismith comber, and a modern cotton comber is in effect a scaled version of a rectilinear comb, its stroke adjusted to the mean fiber length it must handle. In the worsted system a Noble comber was once a common make, but the Noble comb is no longer used there; it may still have uses for the woolen system or for very long fibers of 250 mm and more. The predominant technology for all fibers is the French comb system.

Worsted Yarn, Woolen Yarn and Combed Cotton

Preparation decides the yarn family. Combing arranges fiber in a flat bundle with every fiber going the same direction, and that preparation is commonly used to spin a worsted yarn — smooth, compact and fine. Woolen yarns cannot be spun from fiber prepared with combs; for a woolen yarn the fiber must instead be carded only, keeping the looser, more random arrangement that gives woolen yarns their softness and loft. Combing and carding are therefore partners in sequence for worsted work, but alternatives at the point where the yarn’s character is set.

What the comb throws away is not wasted. When wool is combed, the discarded short fibers are called noils, and they are ground up into shoddy, returning to textile production as a recycled material. For cotton, combing serves quality rather than yarn type: cotton is combed when it is to be used for quality fabric with high thread counts, because a yarn spun from long, parallel fibers weaves into the dense, even cloth those counts require.

Common Questions

What does combing do to fiber?

Combing separates the short fibers out of carded fiber and leaves the remaining fibers straightened and lying parallel to each other in a flat bundle, all going the same direction, ready for spinning.

What are noils?

Noils are the short fibers discarded when wool is combed. They are not spun into worsted yarn; instead they are ground up into shoddy and returned to textile production.

Why is cotton combed?

Cotton is combed when it is to be used for quality fabric with high thread counts. Removing the short fibers leaves longer, parallel fibers that spin into a smoother, finer yarn.

More from Apparel Search: Miscellaneous Definitions  |  Clothing Industry Glossary  |  Fashion Terms  |  Explore Apparel Search